• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Naval Historical Society of Australia

Preserving Australia's Naval History

  • Events
  • Account
  • Members Area
  • Volunteer
  • Donate
  • Contact us
  • Show Search
  • 0 items
Hide Search
Menu
  • Home
  • Research
    • Where to start
      • Research – We can help!
      • Self help
      • Naval Service Records
      • Library
      • Related Maritime websites
    • Resources
      • Articles
      • Videos
      • On This Day
      • Podcasts
      • Australian Military Ship Losses
      • RAN events on a  Google Earth Map
      • RAN Vessels – Where are they now?
      • Related Maritime websites
    • Other
      • Newsletters: Call The Hands
      • Occasional Papers and Historical Booklets
      • Books
      • HMAS Shropshire
      • Book reviews
    • Close
  • Naval Heritage Sites
    • World Heritage Listings
      • Cockatoo Island
    • National Heritage Listings
      • HMAS Sydney II and the HSK Kormoran Shipwreck Sites
      • HMVS Cerberus
    • Commonwealth Heritage Listings
      • Garden Island NSW
      • HMAS Watson
      • HMAS Penguin
      • Spectacle Island Explosives Complex NSW
      • Chowder Bay Naval Facilities
      • Beecroft Peninsula NSW
      • Admiralty House, Garden and Fortifications
      • HMAS Cerberus
      • Naval Offices QLD
      • Garden Island WA
      • Royal Australian Naval College ACT
      • Royal Australian Naval Transmitting Station ACT
    • NSW Heritage Listings
      • HMAS Rushcutter
    • Close
  • Naval Art
  • Tours & Cruises
    • Navy in Sydney Harbour Cruise, East
    • Navy in Sydney Harbour Cruise, West
    • Anniversary Cruise: Sydney under Japanese Attack
    • Tour Bookings
    • Close
  • About us
    • About Us
      • What we do
      • Our People
      • Office Bearers
      • Become a volunteer
      • Our Goals and Strategy
    • Organisation
      • Victoria Chapter
      • WA Chapter
      • ACT Chapter
    • Close
  • Membership
  • Shop
  • Become a volunteer
  • Donate
You are here: Home / Article topics / Publications / Naval Historical Review / The First Battle of Savo Island 8/9 August 1942 – A Correction to the History

The First Battle of Savo Island 8/9 August 1942 – A Correction to the History

Date, John C., RANVR (Rtd) · Sep 16, 1989 · Print This Page

Author
Date, John C., RANVR (Rtd)
Subjects
WWII operations, History - WW2
Tags
Savo Island
RAN Ships
HMAS Canberra I
Publication
September 1989 edition of the Naval Historical Review (all rights reserved)

On the 8/9 August, 1942, a controversial naval battle took place in the Solomon Islands, South West Pacific. It was a rebounding success for the Japanese and a tragic loss to the Allies of four heavy cruisers sunk and considerable damage to other ships resulting in the loss of over 1,000 navy men and with over 700 wounded.

The Japanese admiral took a gamble to attack at night and was to be most surprised with the good fortune that worked in his favour.

The episode began with the first amphibious operation by American ground forces in the retaking of Japanese occupied territories at points of Tulagi and Guadalcanal in the Solomon Islands which was covered by an Allied naval force to protect the transports and landing beachheads.

Situation - 8 August 1942
Situation – 8 August 1942

A strong Japanese force of cruisers had spent the previous day in travelling south from the Rabaul area and in the early hours of the morning of 9 August, 1942 swept round Savo Island, passing between the picquet destroyers Blue and Ralph Talbot both equipped with radar that failed to detect the enemy force, although the Japanese had the destroyers under surveillance. They then surprised the first Allied cruisers, hitting HMAS Canberra which was later to sink and badly damaging the USS Chicago, and continued on to catch unawares, and engage, a second Allied cruiser force consisting of USS Vincennes, Quincy and Astoria, causing the loss of the three cruisers and damage to US destroyers, without any loss to the Japanese ships.

On the immediate scene, some warning was given by the sighting and reporting of Japanese observer planes flying overhead, and by the US destroyer Patterson of unknown ships entering the harbour, but the Allied ships were presumably not prepared to accept the reality of the situation. Individual ship commanders were aware of the Japanese as being within striking distance of Savo Sound and so without the necessity of further direction from their admiral, it was their responsibility to be prepared for any eventuality.

The American historian Samuel Eliot Morison writing ten years after the event (1), named ‘unfortunate circumstances’ for the debacle, one being the lack of communication from a Royal Australian Air Force Lockheed Hudson aircraft A16-218 of 32 Squadron operating out of the Fall River Base, Milne Bay in New Guinea to the sighting of the enemy force at 1026/8 August. Morison went on to say (2) that failures in ship identification and communications were ‘enough to explain why Vice-Admiral Gunichi Mikawa managed to make his approach undetected’. In reality, Morison was stating that the pilot of the Hudson Sgt W.J. Stutt failed to break radio silence, did not return directly to his base with the vital information that he had sighted an enemy force approximately 150 miles from Rabaul but spent the next few hours on reconnaissance and on landing having tea before filing his report. The advice given to Morison appears a misrepresentation of the true facts and now other writers are similarly laying the blame against the lack of reporting from the Australian Hudson plane as the first mistake in a battle of many errors and therefore the main contributing reason for the Savo Island battle disaster.

This is most unfortunate and is entirely incorrect, being at variance to the true facts.

In order to show that Stutt did broadcast an immediate enemy report, a great deal of exhaustive research was undertaken by W.F. Martin Clemens, who is a Companion of the United States and the coastwatcher hero on Guadalcanal; Mrs Lloyd Milne the wife of the pilot of a second Hudson that sighted Mikawa 35 minutes later, and who by checking reports preserved in the Library of War History, Department of the Naval Defence College, Japan, listed the equivalent time of 1027 as receipt by Mikawa of Stutt’s radio message; G. Herman Gill who prepared the Official History of the Royal Australian Navy 1942-45 (published in 1969); and A.J. Sweeting, General Editor of Official War History.

The findings have been most ably presented in a paper by Captain Emile L. Bonnot USNR (Ret) in 1988 (3) stating that ‘Stutt’s radio message from the Hudson plane had been received by the following:

  • USS Vincennes in that Captain Reifkohl the Commanding Officer made mention of it in his orders on the afternoon on 8 August
  • USS Astoria as Lt.Cmdr. Walter B. Davidson said he had a report in the morning
  • USS Enterprise by Lieut and Assistant Gunnery Officer Elias B. Mott saying the report was placed on their Status Board in the early afternoon
  • HMAS Canberra with Cmdr. E.J. Wright, control officer of the after 8” guns, stating that they had the report when he came off watch at sunset
  • MacArthur’s SW Pacific Area Headquarters Station Report No. 350 1817/8 repeated over Bells radio and read by Rear Admiral V.A.C. Crutchley at 1839/8, repeated over Fox radio and read by Rear Admiral R.A. Turner at 1845/8,

and incredibly logged by Mikawa the Japanese admiral at the stated time of transmission.’

Pages: Page 1 Page 2

Naval Historical Review, WWII operations, History - WW2 Savo Island

Primary Sidebar

SUBSCRIBE

Sign up for our monthly e-newsletter.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Categories

Latest Podcasts

  • The Fall of Singapore
  • HMAS Armidale
  • Napoleon, the Royal Navy and Me
  • The Case of the Unknown Sailor
  • Night of the midget subs — Sydney under attack

Links to other podcasts

Australian Naval History Podcasts
This podcast series examines Australia’s Naval history, featuring a variety of naval history experts from the Naval Studies Group and elsewhere.
Produced by the Naval Studies Group in conjunction with the Submarine Institute of Australia, the Australian Naval Institute, Naval Historical Society and the RAN Seapower Centre

Life on the Line Podcasts
Life on the Line tracks down Australian war veterans and records their stories.
These recordings can be accessed through Apple iTunes or for Android users, Stitcher.

Video Links

  • Australian War Memorial YouTube channel
  • Royal Australian Navy YouTube Channel
  • Research – We can help!
  • Naval Heritage Sites
  • Explore Naval Art
  • Dockyard Heritage Tour
  • About us
  • Shop
  • Events
  • Members Area
  • Volunteer
  • Donate
  • Contact us

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Members Area
  • Privacy Policy

Naval Historical Society of Australia Inc. Copyright © 2025