• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Naval Historical Society of Australia

Preserving Australia's Naval History

  • Events
  • Account
  • Members Area
  • Volunteer
  • Donate
  • Contact us
  • Show Search
  • 0 items
Hide Search
Menu
  • Home
  • Research
    • Where to start
      • Research – We can help!
      • Self help
      • Naval Service Records
      • Library
      • Related Maritime websites
    • Resources
      • Articles
      • Videos
      • On This Day
      • Podcasts
      • Australian Military Ship Losses
      • RAN events on a  Google Earth Map
      • RAN Vessels – Where are they now?
      • Related Maritime websites
    • Other
      • Newsletters: Call The Hands
      • Occasional Papers and Historical Booklets
      • Books
      • HMAS Shropshire
      • Book reviews
    • Close
  • Naval Heritage Sites
    • World Heritage Listings
      • Cockatoo Island
    • National Heritage Listings
      • HMAS Sydney II and the HSK Kormoran Shipwreck Sites
      • HMVS Cerberus
    • Commonwealth Heritage Listings
      • Garden Island NSW
      • HMAS Watson
      • HMAS Penguin
      • Spectacle Island Explosives Complex NSW
      • Chowder Bay Naval Facilities
      • Beecroft Peninsula NSW
      • Admiralty House, Garden and Fortifications
      • HMAS Cerberus
      • Naval Offices QLD
      • Garden Island WA
      • Royal Australian Naval College ACT
      • Royal Australian Naval Transmitting Station ACT
    • NSW Heritage Listings
      • HMAS Rushcutter
    • Close
  • Naval Art
  • Tours & Cruises
    • Navy in Sydney Harbour Cruise, East
    • Navy in Sydney Harbour Cruise, West
    • Anniversary Cruise: Sydney under Japanese Attack
    • Tour Bookings
    • Close
  • About us
    • About Us
      • What we do
      • Our People
      • Office Bearers
      • Become a volunteer
      • Our Goals and Strategy
    • Organisation
      • Victoria Chapter
      • WA Chapter
      • ACT Chapter
    • Close
  • Membership
  • Shop
  • Become a volunteer
  • Donate
You are here: Home / Article topics / Publications / Naval Historical Review / Letters: Inquiry into the loss of HMAS Sydney

Letters: Inquiry into the loss of HMAS Sydney

Winter, Barbara · Mar 1, 1999 · Print This Page

Author
Winter, Barbara
Subjects
Ship histories and stories, WWII operations, Letter to the Editor
Tags
Kormoran
RAN Ships
HMAS Sydney II
Publication
March 1999 edition of the Naval Historical Review (all rights reserved)

Ref: Naval Historical Review, Dec. 1998

The generally intelligent and logical analysis by I.H.N. of the communications aspects of the encounter between Sydney and Kormoran falls down in one respect where the writer does not have a sufficient foundation of fact on which to base his deductions.

FACT 1: A list of disguises to be adopted by German raiders and blockade runners was issued before each ship sailed. The commanders had only limited authority to adopt any other disguise. Captain Rogge did briefly assume an unauthorised disguise when he believed that the ship as which he was disguised had been sunk. The disguises were decided at a High Command level, and they had two purposes. One was to enable a raider to get within easy range of a merchant ship without arousing suspicion; the other was to alert the German High Command if one of their ships was in trouble. By the call sign, they knew which ship it was. Thus Atlantis and Pinguin, virtual sister ships, had completely different lists of disguises. It would not have been easy to adopt a new disguise to accommodate an Allied call sign that might have been compromised.

FACT 2: With all due respect to Captain Roskill: he is alleged to have said only that the Germans had gained knowledge of some (repeat SOME) secret call signs. That might have meant three or four. Komet found the secret call sign of Komata, but only after that ship had been boarded then sunk, this was the most frequent cause of a secret call sign becoming known, but obviously it had no operational use. A few, very few, secret call signs were learnt when a careless merchant ship sent a W/T message using its regular call sign, and followed it up fairly soon with one using its secret sign. This was also of no use unless the ship concerned was one as which a raider could plausibly be disguised. I have read the War Diaries of Kormoran, Atlantis, Komet, Pinguin, Orion and Thor, as well as a fair bit of the Seekriegsleitung War Diary, I have found no suggestion that this happened. I have found no evidence that any secret call sign was ever found by capture from another ship or by espionage ashore. Would anyone wishing to contradict me like to do as much work as I have?

FACT 3: A reading of the interrogations of Kormoran crew, especially that of Erich Ahlbach, makes it clear that Detmers had not the faintest idea of what the IK signal was supposed to mean. Ahlbach’s puzzlement is palpable; the story he was telling made little sense to him, but it did to his interrogators.

FACT 4: The story that secret call signs were or could or might have been captured from Automedon is speculation. A list of captured documents shows nothing of the kind. In fact, a secret call sign would not have been considered a very high priority, for a merchant ship was not authorised to ask for the secret call sign of another ship, and in fact would not have recognised it, while the raiders had orders to avoid anything that looked like .an Allied warship.

There has been a truly lamentable tendency to turn “might have been” into “was”, and to base explanations and excuses on such slight foundations, because it allegedly “stands to reason that” something must be so. I am sorry to keep on spoiling people’s fun by asking them to produce real evidence.

Barbara Winter (Poniewierski) (Life Member)


RESPONSE by I.H.N.

None of the “facts” in Barbara Winter’s letter negate the theory of Kormoran‘s use of Straat Malakka‘s secret callsign, including the emphatic denial by the Germans of any knowledge of the secret challenge “IK” (which some reports state was repeated in plain language by morse light). What else would the German prisoners say to questions touching on their likely subterfuge?

There is no definite proof that Kormoran did not hold the secret callsign – nor is there any proof that she did – but the latter appears to be the only logical explanation for the Sydney’s movements and actions during the initial encounter.

It is significant that following the Sydney disaster, and the almost simultaneous sinking of the raider Atlantis in the Atlantic by HMS Devonshire, the Admiralty reviewed merchant ship recognition and identification procedures. Plotting and reporting were improved and a more streamlined system introduced for warships to confirm the identities of merchantmen with their shore HQ’s. It was called the `CHECKMATE” system and generally superseded the challenge and reply method for off-shore use, which had been open to error and liable to compromise.

Pages: Page 1 Page 2

Naval Historical Review, Ship histories and stories, WWII operations, Letter to the Editor Kormoran

Primary Sidebar

SUBSCRIBE

Sign up for our monthly e-newsletter.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Categories

Latest Podcasts

  • The Fall of Singapore
  • HMAS Armidale
  • Napoleon, the Royal Navy and Me
  • The Case of the Unknown Sailor
  • Night of the midget subs — Sydney under attack

Links to other podcasts

Australian Naval History Podcasts
This podcast series examines Australia’s Naval history, featuring a variety of naval history experts from the Naval Studies Group and elsewhere.
Produced by the Naval Studies Group in conjunction with the Submarine Institute of Australia, the Australian Naval Institute, Naval Historical Society and the RAN Seapower Centre

Life on the Line Podcasts
Life on the Line tracks down Australian war veterans and records their stories.
These recordings can be accessed through Apple iTunes or for Android users, Stitcher.

Video Links

  • Australian War Memorial YouTube channel
  • Royal Australian Navy YouTube Channel
  • Research – We can help!
  • Naval Heritage Sites
  • Explore Naval Art
  • Dockyard Heritage Tour
  • About us
  • Shop
  • Events
  • Members Area
  • Volunteer
  • Donate
  • Contact us

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Members Area
  • Privacy Policy

Naval Historical Society of Australia Inc. Copyright © 2025